Heer, There, Everywhere


Adorno: almost as cute as Natalie Portman.

 Natalie Portman: a good beach conversationalist for Adorno?

“What have you been up to?” That’s a question that no reader of this blog has asked me. Still, here is the answer:

1. I’ve been writing literary essays for The Walrus, Canada’s answer to Harper’s or The Atlantic Monthly. My long review essay on “the Holocaust novel” can be found here. It touches on everybody from T.W. Adorno to Natalie Portman to Art Spiegelman.  I also wrote a briefer, but related, review of Keith Oatley’s new novel, a review which can be found on the bottom of this page. Finally, I have a little essay on the difference between reading a writer and listening to him or her read, which is here.

2.  Once again, I was on the Michael Coren show, in an episode which can be seen here. The show ended with an especially heated discussion of the ongoing Catholic sex abuse scandal. Earlier, we debated the merits of Fox News and I was  far too polite. Still, the show might be of interest.

3. For the Comics Journal, I reviewed a new book about the cartoonist Milt Gross, a near forgotten master of Yiddishkeit culture. See here.

 Here are the opening paragraphs of my Walrus review essay:

Few hypothetical scenarios are harder to imagine than a conversation between Theodor Adorno and Natalie Portman. Adorno was the highbrow’s highbrow, the sage Thomas Mann turned to for advice while writing Doctor Faustus, the friend and long-time correspondent of Walter Benjamin, the champion of astringent creators like Arnold Schoenberg, the relentless foe of jazz and Hollywood, the mercilessly pessimistic Marxist critic of modernity whose “negative dialectic” has enriched thousands of scholarly studies. Portman is perhaps best known for her turn as Queen Padmé Amidala in the more mediocre of the two Star Wars trilogies.
Yet on the subject of the Holocaust, Adorno and Portman, both of Jewish heritage, might have found some common ground. In a typically dense 1949 essay titled “Cultural Criticism and Society,” Adorno — a refugee from Nazi Germany who had lost the world of his youth to the Nazi genocide — bluntly declared that “to write poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric.” Arguably, Portman is not as deep a thinker as Adorno (who died in 1969, twelve years before the actress was born), but the starlet has been impressively educated at Harvard and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Interviewed by the Daily Mail earlier this year, she complained, “I get like twenty Holocaust scripts a month, but I hate the genre.”

 Despite their shared discomfort with Holocaust art, an enormous historical and cultural gulf separates Adorno’s statement from Portman’s….

3 thoughts on “Heer, There, Everywhere

  1. Hey there,
    I came across this page in the way that most people probably encounter most internet content: by semi-accident. I was having a conversation with a professor about the Frankfurt School who mentioned this picture of Adorno in a bathing suit; at around the same time someone suggested that I recommend Adorno to the editor of “Bangable Dudes in History” (http://bangabledudesinhistory.blogspot.com/). I figured I’d look up that pic, just for fun (although I ended up nominating Lehmann’s portrait of Franz Liszt).

    As it turns out I’m a big fan of the Walrus. Despite their frequently lousy cover art, the stories are often genuinely searching and offer a level of in-depth thinking about Canadian culture that the New Yorker (my first love) will never provide.

    I am also interested in and distressed by the fact that “holocaust movies” have become a genre; its so weird, only a rigorously Adornian analysis would be adequate to it. Sadly, I couldn’t get access to your article. Just the message:

    Sorry, that article was not found in our system.

    I think the link is broken. Could you update it? Is that content perhaps not publicly available to non-subscribers?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s